Philosophy of Trans-History and Todd Phillips’ Joker in Slavoj Žižek’s Surplus Enjoyment
Abstract
This essay explores an overlooked dimension of Slavoj Žižek's thought: his perspective on, and engagement with, a concrete philosophy of Trans-History. Specifically, it examines the philosophy of Trans-History presented in Surplus Enjoyment. While I do not claim that Žižek constructs a new philosophy of Trans-History in this book, I demonstrate that he directly and consistently engages with this philosophical domain and adopts several premises from Hegelian, Marxist, and Christian philosophies of Trans-History. Building on this analysis, I elucidate Žižek's stance on historicism, his advocacy for the use of theological concepts to understand and safeguard contemporary history, and his interpretation of Todd Phillips’ Joker (2019) as a figure that should not be considered a sociopolitical paradigm for achieving the telos of contemporary history—namely, the unification and cooperation of global societies to avert a looming ecological catastrophe. Additionally, I challenge Žižek's praise of Joker for its portrayal of a profound and ambiguous character symbolizing "self-destructive political nihilism." I argue that this depiction of the Joker lacks originality and merit within the context of the film, as it borrows heavily from the Joker's extensive history in comics, a legacy dating back to 1940 and shaped by numerous writers.
Keywords
Philosophy of History, Teleology, New Social Order, Political nihilism, DC Comics Joker
References
- Burton, T. (Director). (1989). Batman [Film]. Warner Bros.
- Englehart, S. (Writer), Rogers, M. (Artist), & Austin, T. (Inker). (2014). The laughing fish / The sign of the Joker. In R. Wildman (Ed.), The Joker: A celebration of 75 years (pp. 165–200). DC Comics. (Reprinted from Detective Comics, Nos. 475–476)
- Finger, B. (Writer), Schwartz, L. S. (Artist), & Roussos, G. (Inker). (1951). The man behind the Red Hood. Detective Comics, (168). DC Comics.
- Grant, A. (Writer), Breyfogle, N. (Artist), & Mitchell, S. (Inker). (1990). Anarky in Gotham City, Part One: Letters to the editor. Detective Comics, (608). DC Comics.
- Inoue, Y. (2023, July 31). Tokyo “Joker” train attacker sentenced to 23-year prison term. The Japan Times. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2023/07/31/japan/crime-legal/tokyo-joker-train-attacker-sentence/
- Moore, A. (Writer), Bolland, B. (Artist), & Starkings, R. (Letterer). (1988). Batman: The killing joke [Graphic novel]. DC Comics.
- Morrison, G. (Writer), & McKean, D. (Artist). (2020). Batman: Arkham Asylum [Graphic novel]. DC Comics.
- Nolan, C. (Director). (2008). The dark knight [Film]. Warner Bros.
- Phillips, T. (Director). (2019). Joker [Film]. Warner Bros.
- Reed, D. V. (Writer), Moldoff, S. (Artist), & Paris, C. (Inker). (2014). Batman: Clown of crime. In R. Wildman (Ed.), The Joker: A celebration of 75 years (pp. 114–123). DC Comics. (Reprinted from Batman, No. 85)
- Shelton, J. (2024). 16 real-life crimes and murders inspired by the Joker. Ranker. https://www.ranker.com/list/real-events-inspired-by-the-joker/jacob-shelton
- Žižek, S. (2023). Surplus enjoyment: A guide for the non-perplexed. Bloomsbury.