Vol. 7 (2025)

Essay

Philosophy of Trans-History and Todd Phillips’ Joker in Slavoj Žižek’s Surplus Enjoyment

Published 20-01-2024

  • Dr. Francisco Miguel Ortiz Delgado

Dr. Francisco Miguel Ortiz Delgado
Universidad de Guadalajara, México

Abstract

This essay explores an overlooked dimension of Slavoj Žižek's thought: his perspective on, and engagement with, a concrete philosophy of Trans-History. Specifically, it examines the philosophy of Trans-History presented in Surplus Enjoyment. While I do not claim that Žižek constructs a new philosophy of Trans-History in this book, I demonstrate that he directly and consistently engages with this philosophical domain and adopts several premises from Hegelian, Marxist, and Christian philosophies of Trans-History. Building on this analysis, I elucidate Žižek's stance on historicism, his advocacy for the use of theological concepts to understand and safeguard contemporary history, and his interpretation of Todd Phillips’ Joker (2019) as a figure that should not be considered a sociopolitical paradigm for achieving the telos of contemporary history—namely, the unification and cooperation of global societies to avert a looming ecological catastrophe. Additionally, I challenge Žižek's praise of Joker for its portrayal of a profound and ambiguous character symbolizing "self-destructive political nihilism." I argue that this depiction of the Joker lacks originality and merit within the context of the film, as it borrows heavily from the Joker's extensive history in comics, a legacy dating back to 1940 and shaped by numerous writers.

Keywords

Philosophy of History, Teleology, New Social Order, Political nihilism, DC Comics Joker

PDF (Spanish)

References

  1. Burton, T. (director). (1989). Batman. Warner Bros.
  2. Englehart, S. (guión), Rogers, M. (dibujo) y Austin, T. (tintas). (2014). The Laughing Fish / The
  3. Sign of the Joker. Detective Comics #475-476. En Robin Wildman (ed.). The Joker: A
  4. Celebration of 75 Years (pp. 165-200). DC Comics.
  5. Finger, B. (guión), Sayre Schwarts, L. (dibujo) y Roussos, G. (tintas). (1951). The Man Behind the
  6. Red Hood. Detective Comics, 168. DC Comics.
  7. Grant, A. (guión), Breyfogle, N. (dibujo) y Mitchell, S. (tintas). (1990). Anarky in Gotham City,
  8. Part One: Letters to the Editor. Detective Comics #608. DC Comics.
  9. Inoue, Y. (2023). Tokyo ‘Joker’ train attacker sentenced to 23-year prison term. The Japan Times.
  10. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2023/07/31/japan/crime-legal/tokyo-joker-train-
  11. attacker-sentence/
  12. Moore, A. (guión), Bolland, B. (dibujo) y Starkings, R. (tintas). (1988). Batman: The Killing Joke.
  13. DC Comics.
  14. Morrison, G. (guión) y McKean, D. (dibujo). (2020). Batman: Arkham Asylum. DC Comics.
  15. Nolan, C. (director). (2008). The Dark Knight. Warner Bros.
  16. Phillips, T. (director). (2019). Joker. Warner Bros.
  17. Reed, D. V. (guión), Moldoff, S. (dibujo) y Paris, C. (tintas). (2014). Batman -Clown of Crime.
  18. Batman #85. En Robin Wildman (ed.). The Joker: A Celebration of 75 Years (pp. 114-123).
  19. DC Comics.
  20. Shelton, J. (2024). 16 Real-Life Crimes and Murders Inspired By The Joker. Ranker. https://www.
  21. ranker.com/list/real-events-inspired-by-the-joker/jacob-shelton
  22. Žižek, S. (2023). Surplus Enjoyment. A Guide for the Non-Perplexed. Bloombsbury.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.